721 Atlantic Ave N

Cape May, NJ 08204
List Price
$1,100,000
721 Atlantic Ave N
721 Atlantic Ave N - Image 2
721 Atlantic Ave N - Image 3
More photos

Why I Like This Property

“This property stands out because of its excellent location, strong rental history, and potential for above-market returns.”

Login to view details
Cody Zucker
Cody Zucker
Savvy STR Agent

About This Property

Newly Priced: This will NOT last Make your appointment Today. This one-of-a-kind property is situated on an oversized 70x125 corner lot just one block from the bayfront and within walking distance to the Ferry Terminal, offering incredible expansion potential and the ultimate coastal lifestyle. Featuring 3 bedrooms and 2.5 baths, this home boasts an open-concept kitchen, living, and dining area designed for comfortable everyday living and entertaining alike. A spacious Florida all-season room, added in 2018, features a cozy corner wood stove, creating the perfect atmosphere for winter evenings. The home also offers natural gas heat, central air and split unit and alternative AC unit in Master. The owner also added a supplemental mini-split system to the open concept area to keep you comfortable year-round. Additional highlights include a separate laundry room and abundant storage throughout. Step outside into the huge, fenced yard and check out the backyard oasis where peace and tranquility await. The 10x16 in-ground pool with a unique feature in the pool surround seating creates the perfect setting for summer fun and outdoor entertaining. The oversized 20x30 detached garage is truly exceptional, featuring running water, extensive storage, and endless possibilities for hobbyists, crafters and or woodwork enthusiasts. Above the garage, enjoy a stunning 20x30 rooftop fiberglass deck with breathtaking bay views, unforgettable sunsets, and front-row seats to fireworks displays. Plantation shutters throughout the home add a beachy, comfortable, and private feel to the home. The oversized corner lot also provides ample off-street parking for guests. This property is being sold furnished (inventory list to be provided, excluding a few personal items) and is offered strictly AS-IS, turnkey, and ready for one-of-a-kind enjoyment. Sellers request that closing take place no earlier than September 15th, allowing them one final summer season while giving the new owners the opportunity to enjoy the quieter and most beautiful time of year at the shore. Whether you are looking for a year-round residence, vacation getaway, or investment property with excellent seasonal rental income potential, this home checks every box—especially with the highly desirable in-ground pool feature. Enjoy peaceful morning walks along the bayfront, bike rides to the Ferry Terminal concerts and events, easy beach access just steps away, and convenient proximity to Cape May. Schedule your private showing today—this incredible shore property will not last long! GETTING AROUND (measured drive times): Delaware Bay beach access — 0.4 mi (2 min drive / 10-min walk) · Cape May–Lewes Ferry — 0.5 mi (2 min) · Washington Street Mall / Cape May historic district — 3.6 mi (10 min) · Sunset Beach, Cape May Point — 2.2 mi (14 min) · Wildwood Boardwalk / Morey's Piers — 8.1 mi (18 min).

Luxury
Family-friendly
Romantic-getaway
Beach
Super Property
Hot Tub
Pool
Bay View
Rooftop Deck
Fire Pit
Ev Charger
Firepit

Property Details

3
Bedrooms
3
Bathrooms
1,250
Square Feet
1964
Year Built
0.20 ac
Lot Size
Single Family
Property Type

Projected Opportunity

Revenue Range
Projected ROI (optimized)
Avg Daily Rate
Avg Occupancy

Comparable Airbnb Listings

Revenue data from similar short-term rentals in the area

Secluded bayside retreat w/ pool

Secluded bayside retreat w/ pool

Lower Township, NJ

ADR
Occupancy
Revenue
Login to view details
View on Airbnb
Beach Therapy-Pool-100 Yrds-Beach-Gym-Golf-Bocce

Beach Therapy-Pool-100 Yrds-Beach-Gym-Golf-Bocce

Cape May, NJ

ADR
Occupancy
Revenue
Login to view details
View on Airbnb
Villa By the Bay Private Heated Pool & Hot Tub

Villa By the Bay Private Heated Pool & Hot Tub

North Cape May, NJ

ADR
Occupancy
Revenue
Login to view details
View on Airbnb
Bayside Salt Water Pool Oasis - POOLS OPEN

Bayside Salt Water Pool Oasis - POOLS OPEN

Cape May, NJ

ADR
Occupancy
Revenue
Login to view details
View on Airbnb
Mimosa Salt Water Pool & HOT TUB Oasis, Sleeps 8

Mimosa Salt Water Pool & HOT TUB Oasis, Sleeps 8

Cape May, NJ

ADR
Occupancy
Revenue
Login to view details
View on Airbnb
YEAR ROUND Beachfront Pool Paradise Cape May Beach

YEAR ROUND Beachfront Pool Paradise Cape May Beach

Lower Township, NJ

ADR
Occupancy
Revenue
Login to view details
View on Airbnb

Savvy Recommended Upgrades

Hot tub (year-round)

Est. $10,000$7,500

Rooftop deck build-out over 20x30 garage - string lights, al-fresco dining, hammock, fire pit + Adirondack chairs, 2-hole putt-putt green

Est. $15,000

Interior design refresh + sleeps-10 conversion (quality pull-outs, bunk config)

Est. $10,000

Professional furnishing package (design-led, sleeps-10 layout)

Est. $25,000

Professional photography + drone multimedia package (aerial bay views + rooftop deck)

Est. $5,000

EV Charger

Est. $2,000$7,500

Your Agent

Cody Zucker

Cody Zucker

STR Investment Specialist

Jersey Shore, NJ

5
Deals Closed
8
Years Experience

Investment Calculator

Calculate your potential returns with real property data

Est. Monthly Cash Flow
Cash-on-Cash Return

Listing agent: Dagmer Chew. Listing courtesy of HOMESTEAD REAL ESTATE CO. INC.. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Financial & Investment Disclaimer: All information on this website is for informational purposes only and is believed accurate to the best of our knowledge but is not guaranteed. Nothing constitutes financial, tax, legal, or investment advice. All investments involve risk and you may lose some or all of your capital. Projections, case studies, and examples are illustrative only and not guarantees of future results. Agents operate independently under their own brokerages. Savvy may receive affiliate or referral compensation. Intended primarily for US residents. Conduct your own due diligence and consult your own professionals. Full disclosure applies.